2. Marco Cruz
3. Milton Pike
4. Avery Marx
Mama Nettie's file in the game contains their profiles, as compiled by NYPD cop Thomas Deacon. The notes consist of sketches, general information about the killers and the poems they left on the crime scenes.
None of the Five are mortal men any more, as they each carry one Dark Soul. When they take damage in combat or are almost beaten, their appearance starts to resemble that of a Trueform. To defeat them, Shadowman has to destroy them with the ShadowGun after they took enough damage.